Zen in Your Karate?
Zen in Your Karate?
Hi all. Can somebody point me to an objective historical look at the relationship of Buddhism and Karate? I've studied Zen Buddhism for several years and have several questions where they may or may not overlap. Thanks in advance.
Sorry, I don't know of any objective historical book, but I assume you are familiar with what Shoshin Nagamine has written about it. Easy to google that. Perhaps a bit more obscure is a comment he made to L.W.Preston, as recorded in her journal ( http://www.sczenkarate.org/ ):
So, this suggests that the connection with zen may not be a strong one in Okinawa, historically speaking. Nagamine himself was not taught by his masters to mix the two. What about Chinese martial arts, however?He further stated that hardly anyone or rather no one he knows has adopted zen, has married zen to karate as he has. He asked me if I knew of dojo in America that has done so and I said no. He went on to make me promise to teach zen as he had taught me.
Mike
Thanks for your response. I got into Zen as a teenager and have spent plenty of hours sitting, reading and talking with the occasional monk. During this I've never come across references to martial arts. Yet during my brief study of Karate I've heard some say the Bodhidarma himself invented Sanchin. I find that hard to believe and would like to hear or read something from a trustworthy historian on the subject. It's an odd position, I greatly desire to marry my two favorite subjects but not in an untruthful or misunderstood way.
If the dojo was also the zendo I would never leave the building.
I'm just yapping, feel free to sharply correct my error. I'll order some literature by Nagamine. I did have one of his books but suspect I didn't read it closely enough. I'll try again. Thanks.
If the dojo was also the zendo I would never leave the building.
I'm just yapping, feel free to sharply correct my error. I'll order some literature by Nagamine. I did have one of his books but suspect I didn't read it closely enough. I'll try again. Thanks.
-
- Posts: 1573
- Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2005 7:05 am
Just a thought from a non-buddhist, if one is a buddhist, how can one's karate not be buddhist?
How is zen separate from karate? Or basket weaving, for that matter.
Also, why do you find it hard to believe that the Bhodidharma created sanchin? Personally I don't care who created it, but someone did. So who created sanchin, and why should I care?
If the patron saint of Chinese buddhism didn't create sanchin, does that make sanchin somehow less zen, or shall we say chan?
I find it hard to believe that Jesus Christ ever lived, but it doesn't seem to have any affect on the truth of what he taught.
What if the Buddha never existed? Would that have any impact on the validity of what he taught.
A rose is a rose is a rose.![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol.gif)
How is zen separate from karate? Or basket weaving, for that matter.
Also, why do you find it hard to believe that the Bhodidharma created sanchin? Personally I don't care who created it, but someone did. So who created sanchin, and why should I care?
If the patron saint of Chinese buddhism didn't create sanchin, does that make sanchin somehow less zen, or shall we say chan?
I find it hard to believe that Jesus Christ ever lived, but it doesn't seem to have any affect on the truth of what he taught.
What if the Buddha never existed? Would that have any impact on the validity of what he taught.
![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol.gif)
A rose is a rose is a rose.
![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol.gif)
"Just a thought from a non-Buddhist, if one is a Buddhist, how can one's karate not be Buddhist?"
I must of course agree with you on that.
"Also, why do you find it hard to believe that the Bhodidharma created sanchin? Personally I don't care who created it, but someone did. So who created sanchin, and why should I care?"
It seems that it is best to attempt to be truthful with students. If they find out through independent investigation that you have been giving them inaccurate information you will lose their trust. And it seems that is not beneficial to anyone.
"What if the Buddha never existed? Would that have any impact on the validity of what he taught."
Are you sure you're not a Buddhist?
I must of course agree with you on that.
"Also, why do you find it hard to believe that the Bhodidharma created sanchin? Personally I don't care who created it, but someone did. So who created sanchin, and why should I care?"
It seems that it is best to attempt to be truthful with students. If they find out through independent investigation that you have been giving them inaccurate information you will lose their trust. And it seems that is not beneficial to anyone.
"What if the Buddha never existed? Would that have any impact on the validity of what he taught."
Are you sure you're not a Buddhist?
"I find it hard to believe that Jesus Christ ever lived, but it doesn't seem to have any affect on the truth of what he taught."
I completely disagree with this. It is quite easy to believe that Jesus lived, as there's plenty of evidence to support this. It's just hard for a critical mind to accept that he was the son of God and could break the rules of physics. And as far as the truth of what he taught, that's up for debate. There are some statements in the new testament that don't ring true, to me. It may be different for you. So I think understanding the historical, probable, Jesus is useful. Just as understanding the historical Buddha is useful and not some later addition by a possibly less enlightened political group.
Questions can only help clarify, even if the answer is, we don't know. Saying I don't know is far better than saying something untrue.
So I'd like to do some research and try to answer some questions. It seemed asking here first would be a good place to start. I'm going to bug a Buddhist forum next.
Please feel free to disagree. I bet you'll say something I didn't know and help me learn.
I completely disagree with this. It is quite easy to believe that Jesus lived, as there's plenty of evidence to support this. It's just hard for a critical mind to accept that he was the son of God and could break the rules of physics. And as far as the truth of what he taught, that's up for debate. There are some statements in the new testament that don't ring true, to me. It may be different for you. So I think understanding the historical, probable, Jesus is useful. Just as understanding the historical Buddha is useful and not some later addition by a possibly less enlightened political group.
Questions can only help clarify, even if the answer is, we don't know. Saying I don't know is far better than saying something untrue.
So I'd like to do some research and try to answer some questions. It seemed asking here first would be a good place to start. I'm going to bug a Buddhist forum next.
Please feel free to disagree. I bet you'll say something I didn't know and help me learn.
-
- Posts: 1573
- Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2005 7:05 am
Yes, that was an interesting and excellent book. My martial arts and philosophy books are packed away right now, otherwise I'd list a number of similar books for discussion.
Also, I apologize for being remiss in my duties and wish to welcome eric, fivedragons, and mhosea to this forum. Your contributions, opinions and thoughts can only help to educate us all...
Take care...
Panther
Also, I apologize for being remiss in my duties and wish to welcome eric, fivedragons, and mhosea to this forum. Your contributions, opinions and thoughts can only help to educate us all...
Take care...
Panther
-
- Posts: 1573
- Joined: Thu Mar 17, 2005 7:05 am
In the interest of synchronicity, this was just posted on Van's forum:
Quote:
"Goju Sanchin Article
Here are a few great references from Mike Clark's Sodokan Goju Ryu web page from England:
http://www.gojukarate.co.uk/sodokan005.htm
The philosophy of Hakkei or explosive power of Sanchin:
http://www.gojukarate.co.uk/sodokan015.htm
The 3 conflicts or 3 jewels of Sanchin:
http://www.gojukarate.co.uk/sodokan006.htm
Enjoy!!
_________________
Jim Prouty" -end quote
New England Budo Center
Quote:
"Goju Sanchin Article
Here are a few great references from Mike Clark's Sodokan Goju Ryu web page from England:
http://www.gojukarate.co.uk/sodokan005.htm
The philosophy of Hakkei or explosive power of Sanchin:
http://www.gojukarate.co.uk/sodokan015.htm
The 3 conflicts or 3 jewels of Sanchin:
http://www.gojukarate.co.uk/sodokan006.htm
Enjoy!!
_________________
Jim Prouty" -end quote
New England Budo Center
-
- Posts: 28
- Joined: Thu Jul 22, 2010 1:09 am
Zen, and Karate.
deletion by author
Last edited by Thomas Ferguson on Tue Sep 21, 2010 6:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- gmattson
- Site Admin
- Posts: 6070
- Joined: Wed Sep 16, 1998 6:01 am
- Location: Lake Mary, Florida
- Contact:
Thanks for the information
Thomas:
Very Interesting.
Thanks for your input.
Very Interesting.
Thanks for your input.
GEM
"Do or do not. there is no try!"
"Do or do not. there is no try!"