There was a discussion today at the judges meeting regarding the age requirement for junior black belts, and whether there was one or not. Here is the applicable section, right from this website's Federation page. Click it and read it yourself, if you'd like.
It is clear that students under the age of 11 may not test for junior black belt. The minimum age is 11 y.o.Chapter 2:
Junior Ratings:
2.1. Background:
IUKF encourages teachers to provide an interesting and informative curriculum for their junior members. IUKF does not make any distinctions between its juniors and seniors. Teachers provide the very finest instruction, regardless of age. A detailed, time proven curriculum is provided to the IUKF dojo for students under the age of 16. IUKF require that adult ratings are not awarded to anyone under the age of 16. Therefore, our junior members wear different colored belts until their 11th birthday, when they qualify for a Junior Black Belt (emphasis added). When a student turns 16, the student may be tested for an adult rank.
2.2. Junior Belts and Stripes Promotions:
2.2.1. White Belt: With one, two and three yellow stripes.
2.2.2. Yellow Belt: With one, two and three orange stripes.
2.2.3. Orange Belt: With one, two and three blue stripes.
2.2.4. Blue Belt: With one, two and three red stripes
2.2.5. Red Belt: The plain red belt is the highest Junior rating for students under the age of 11. (emphasis added)
2.2.6. Junior Black Belt:.
Juniors between the ages of 11 and 16 qualify for the rank of Junior Black Belt. This belt has a white stripe running the length of the belt to distinguish it from the adult black belt.
Does anyone think otherwise?
Now here's the question:
Little Johnny, a precocious 9 y.o. IUKF JBB wants to compete in the Boy's 13 and Under fighting division. May the center ref disallow him from fighting, for his rank is in violation of the established ranking charter? Is it safe for him fight, when all his opponents will be at least 11 y.o?
Does this ruling extend to the under 11 y.o. JBB of other organizations who also compete?
May the judge disallow the underage fighter, purely on a safety basis?
Gene